No longer passing the Buc(k)?

Sir George Buc’s patron and dedicatee Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel and Surrey, later Earl of Norfolk. He was also Earl Marshal and Constable of England. Portrait by Peter Paul Rubens

Now for some very interesting news: Arthur Kincaid’s The History of King Richard the Third is set for a new edition, based on forty years of further research. Kincaid has managed to distinguish the forensic research of Sir George Buc (1560-1622), whose great-grandfather fought at Bosworth and whose grandfather was at Flodden, from that of his great-nephew George Buck, who tried to hijack his fame and greatly over-egged the pudding. His mangled 1646 version, The History of the Life and Reign of Richard III, is frequently assumed by modern historians (including Kendall) to be the original, thus adversely affecting Buc’s credibility, with particular reference to the Elizabeth of York/ Norfolk letter about the plans for the Portuguese marriages. Though it was somewhat damaged in a 1731 fire at Sir Robert Cotton’s library, Buc’s British Library original (fragment below) was available to Kincaid in other ways.

Buc was an authentic and original antiquarian, as well as a contemporary of Shakespeare, whose work he knew to be unreliable. He had rediscovered, through the Crowland Chronicle, a reference to Titulus Regius 1484, that had apparently been totally suppressed two years later, attesting to the pre-contract.

So now we know what Sir George Buc wrote during his lifetime, unblemished by his near namesake great-nephew. Thanks to Annette Carson, in the same year, we know precisely what Domenico Mancini wrote rather than what CAJ Armstrong thought last century. What now of More, whose manuscript escaped eight years after his execution, but whose family and followers may similarly have distorted it?

By super blue

Grandson of a Town player.


  1. I did a search for the new edition, but only found the last one, 1981. Can you let us know when it’s released? Many thanks.


  2. I gave a full article to Murrey & Blue about Arthur Kincaid and his new edition of Buc(k), an edition which I was instrumental in bringing to fruition, although it hasn’t been published yet. And I provided these two images to illustrate my article … only this isn’t it. So, my fox has been shot.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: